Advertisement

Editorial: Pension reform deserves public debate

February 13, 2013|By Robert Lang

Democracy only works from the bottom up. Unfortunately, there was a breakdown in this most basic of democratic principles at last week's City Council candidate forum.

The breakdown had nothing to do with the candidates, all of whom appear to be fine men. Nor did it have anything to do with the eloquent Peter Bachmann, the event moderator; or the five rainbow-sprinkled sugar cookies that disappeared before my very eyes.

What did go seriously awry was the review and rephrasing process built into the question-and-answer period. When it came to my query, the panel of three “parsers” turned a serious issue into a muddled mess. All within the rules, of course: “Questions may be consolidated or rephrased” was clearly displayed on the handouts.

Advertisement

My question pertained to the high cost of public-sector salaries and benefits and whether or not the candidates would be willing to look at cost-saving alternatives. Unfortunately, it has become politically incorrect to even mention that tens of thousands of state educators, department heads and public safety workers will soon be retiring on $100,000-plus, cost-of-living adjusted pensions with full healthcare benefits for life. Public-sector salaries and benefits are the real financial daggers aimed at our throats; that's where the real money is. If we do not immediately take steps to rein in these runaway costs, we will soon find ourselves being reigned over by bureaucrats who believe they can get away with anything because they have.

The question I submitted for the candidates was: “Public-sector salaries and benefits are becoming unaffordable. Would you support the establishment of a working group/standing committee to investigate the feasibility of a full or partial volunteer fire department (along the lines of Sierra Madre) and/or a private security patrol/traffic enforcement service to relieve the Sheriff's Department of routine law enforcement tasks?”

The three parsers turned this into: “Are there ways to relieve the Sheriff's Department of routine tasks?” Even I was puzzled by its intent, but it got me thinking.

La Canada Valley Sun Articles La Canada Valley Sun Articles
|
|
|