To a degree, it was expected by some people and a surprise to others that La Cañada had two first-team players.
Shoemake, who also played outfield, said he dreamed of making the All-Rio Hondo League's first-team, but never put in a full season on the varsity squad until his senior campaign because of injuries he suffered as a sophomore and junior.
"It was good to get some recognition," Shoemake said. "Last year was the year I could have made it, but I got injured. It does feel really good this year because I worked really hard. It was time."
As much as Shoemake appreciates the individual praise, he still wishes La Cañada could have put together a better season. The Spartans finished the year 11-11 (5-7 in the Rio Hondo League) and had their season end at the hands of Summit High of Fontana in the CIF Southern Section Division IV wild-card round, losing on the road, 8-3.
"It was a fun year. I just wish we could have pulled out a couple more victories," Shoemake said.
Stetson and Shoemake led the Spartans to the success they did have, putting together a three-game winning streak to qualify for a wild-card berth in the CIF Southern Section Division IV playoffs.
For a part of the season, the two were La Cañada's No. 3 and 4 hitters, until Stetson was moved to the lead-off spot and Shoemake to the three hole for the last part of the season. No matter where they hit in the order, they produced.
Stetson was responsible for the Spartans' highest batting average — .429 (27 for 63). His .486 one-base average and .571 slugging percentage and three triples were also team bests. The Chapman-University-bound catcher drove in nine runs and scored 14 times. He stole seven bases, struck out four times and made just one error on 34 chances all season.