Soccer was soon phased out of Coffey's life and she took to volleyball. She played for Sacred Heart's soccer team during her freshman year but gave it up after to solely concentrate on volleyball, which she refers to as her "best sport."
"She really is too well-rounded," Sacred Heart volleyball Coach Anne Arlie said. "She plays aggressively on both offense and defense. Her mentality is to always put the ball away — never let it drop. She's always concentrated on digging or killing the ball."
Her mindset paid off this year as Coffey was named the Mission League's co-Most Valuable Player. She guided the Tologs to a 6-3 Mission League record, a second-place finish behind Harvard-Westlake and an appearance in CIF Southern Section Division I-AA playoffs.
Coffey led the team in nearly every stat, including kills (241), digs (162), blocks (19) and aces (eight).
An All-Area first-team selection in 2008 and 2009, Coffey's final season earned her the title of the 2010 All-Area Girls' Volleyball Player of the Year as voted by the sports editors and writers of the Burbank Leader, Glendale News-Press and La Cañada Valley Sun.
The Tologs didn't enter the 2010 season as league favorites. They were a young team, having graduated eight seniors and returning just four varsity starters.
"We actually did a lot better than most people expected," Coffey said. "They expected us to drop off and not make the playoffs, but we fought really hard and we did."
Sacred Heart fought through a tough league schedule and advanced to the postseason. The Tologs lost to Edison 25-15, 25-20, 25-22 in the first round.
Still, Coffey said the challenge of rebuilding and the success that came with it made her senior year the most rewarding.